Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Lean Startup Mentor Awards

As you may know, AppSumo ran a great contest for Lean Startups, and I've listed the winners below. Although we didn't win, we're really thankful for the SXSW bundle, and the opportunity to put our views down on paper, if you will. All of these companies are very, very lucky - mentorship is what makes incubators/funds like i/o ventures, 500 Startups, and YC so much more than just investment dollars. Enjoy it!

Thank you as well for everyone who did vote for us - I'll be sending you a personal email later today. That said, you really should check out these winning entries, and AppSumo - it's a great resource for deals for startup junkies like me, and if you're reading this, like you.

Time to get back to work. Check out these great blog entries and the amazing entrepreneurs behind them.

Eric Ries and Parker Thompson will mentor the authors of "A Lean Mean Startup Machine"

Patrick Vaskovitz and Dan Martell will mentor the authors of "Lean...it's how we roll"

Andrew Chen will mentor the authors of "Lean Startup Guide to Building Software for Normals"

Dave McClure will mentor the authors of "Lean Startup Challenge"

Hiten Shah will mentor the authors of "Lean Startup (Day to Day) Challenge"

Noah Kagan and Ramit Sethi will mentor the authors of "How we are launching 15Five on $950"

Brad Feld will mentor the authors of "Using Lean to Get Elite University Students Top Tier Job Offers"

Rashmi and Brant Cooper will mentor the authors of "Keeping my startup lean like beef jerky"

David Hauser and Aaron Bell will mentor the authors of "Why rFave is a lean startup"

Ash Maurya will mentor the authors of "Team TripLingo:11 Ways we're lean & 1 way we're not"

Dharmesh Shah and Jason Cohen will mentor the team at Pizza Powered, who actually won twice (!) for their products EmberAds and SEOMEeasure. Nice work Pizza Powered. Just proves, I've been doing it wrong with this Red Bull, should be using Pizza.   







Monday, March 28, 2011

Quora: Thank or Vote? And Why it's important

This may seem like a really simple question, but I'm very interested in your answer - when you use Quora, do you use the "Send Thanks" option, vote things up, or both? I was struck by this today when reviewing one of the questions on everyones-favorite-topic, Color. Love them or Hate them, we can't seem to get enough of them.

I wanted to see how much they spent getting such a great domain name, to try to get an idea of what assets they were capturing with their $41 million dollar investment. There were two answers on the site, one of which was from the President and Co-Founder, Peter Pham. Peter validated the exact amount. You can see it here:

In my opinion, it's amazing to see it validated, but not vote-worthy. I don't think I'm overstating, either, that it's amazing, and the value of Quora to the community. It has become a forum for informed disclosure. Color is getting hammered for their gigantic raise, with many people wanting to call it proof we are in a new bubble. If you are outside Silicon Valley, you may not appreciate what a dirty, dirty word "bubble" is to throw at a company. That said, Peter validated the expense, which at $350,000 is  about the the total sum of 10 or 12 popular angel-backed startups.

If you are in the middle of a PR fire-storm about money, it would have been easy for Peter to simply avoid the question, and yet, there it is, confirmed. This represents a brilliant change of pace; 10 years ago, most companies would have asked to for an NDA before even admitting what their domain was going to be. Back then, stealth was the new black, and thankfully those times are slowly going away. So I applaud Peter and Color for answering it on Quora. For that, I clicked the "send thanks" link. But I didn't vote it up.

See, I didn't consider his answer "vote-worthy". It's a fact, so in what context does that vote have any meeting. The question was very clear, very direct ("How Much?") and was answered specifically, with a number. It's not an opinion, or really even a choice. Voting is usually about choosing one thing over others, independent of if you are picking the next president president or deciding where to go for lunch. I think this metaphor is well established, and comes through us in our expectations as users. I think it's a little broken, or at least confused, in Quora.

The case against using voting might be even more clear in the case of a person - like this example on @sacca - do we vote for that? Or Thank that? I don't see how anyone else could be "more right" to explain what Chris Sacca thought than Chris Sacca.

I can't find anything on Quora on when to vote and when to thank - I checked the FAQ for New Users,  the official policies and guidelines, and the Getting Started Guide. I probably missed it, but seems like it should be more transparent.

A number of people have already talked about the problems with voting from such angles as Celebrity Up voting, the Paretro distribution problem (my favorite of the design implications), and others. Semil Shah wrote an excellent summary on TechCrunch, so there is no reason to repeat those points.

I think voting is fundamentally a bad design metaphor that leads to problems when Quora wants to start mining this data. Today, the Vote button is not really voting, in the way we experience it in the physical world; it acts much more like a Facebook "Like" button. Voting is a choice, selecting among a fixed set possible answers. This is our "real world" experience, but on Quora, new answers may be coming in at all times.  However, the very idea that I can change my vote when presented with new options breaks the voting metaphor again, as voting usually has a fixed set of choices. As you can tell, I'm really struggling with voting as a design principal. It's easy on the surface, but very hard in the implementation, which I think will lead to bad, or interpreted data, getting into the system. I'm not the first to talk about the issues of Quora voting.

That said, I think the "killer concept" in Quora might be the Thanks concept. I wish it was more clear in the UX and had some basic guidelines. I think Thanks could be the foundation for creating an authenticity rating, or other scoring subsystem, which doesn't yet exist on the web. Wikipedia only has in some very basic, nearly secretive, awards for super-contributors. If the Facebook "like" becomes the currency of my interests, is there a currency for something more human? How do we encourage people like Sacca and Peter Pham to continue to be transparent on the the most anonymous communications system ever built?

Now, I have no knowledge of Quora's design or inner working. I hope it's possible in Quora's back end data to see, what the possible choices were at the time when someone voted.  It may be possible that they know how they want to used Thank and Vote data, but it's far to opaque to the user right now to be actionable.  I'm a Quora fan and a data purist, so I keep toying with the idea in my head - nothing more.

What do you think? How do you use Thanks and Voting in Quora? Can Thanks be a new currency that promotes transparency?

I'd really like to hear what you think, please drop an idea in the comments or hit me up on twitter.

Saturday, March 26, 2011

Dave McClure ruins my Saturday morning

So it's Saturday morning. Now that I've moved on to Startup #2, I'm trying to blog a lot more. Today, I planned on finishing up, or at least moving forward, three blog posts I'm working on (Yobongo as MVP, Knowledge Navigator Birthday, and how to improve Klout), but Dave McClure totally ruined those plans, because he posted this on Twitter:


Now, this would be 500 times easier (yes, that's an subliminal number, for those of you playing along at home) if he said Disqus, since that's a big part of the Klout posting. I could have at least cut and pasted a lot of it, or ignored it all together, assuming I'd address it some other time. But it sat there on my screen, mocking me, this question. Look, it's only been a hour, so I'm not going to make this my tell-tale-heart, but it was stuck in my head. So, here's my brain dump on what hit me this morning. 

I took the question as "how could/would you monetize Quora,and the concepts of Influence". 

Influence is clearly one of the next great issue with the web, which is how do we value the sources from which we get information? How can we come up with a TransUnion/Equifax/Experian creditscore system for the web? I want to make that reference again - to credit scores - because most people talk about their Credit Score (note the lack of plural), although there are three private agencies that make up your final FICO score. This is not a winner-take-all game, but for the big winners, of which, there will be a few, it's gigantic. Web influence is a currency that will be, if it is not already, as powerful as your FICO score. This is the area where I think Quora can build an amazing (consumer and professional) brand, long term value, and be influential in a wide range of transactions. 

Influence is the oft-discussed value of the social graph, based in the idea we will follow people we trust, we know, we like, or we want to know. Ironically, the reasons I just listed are not recorded anywhere. I have no idea why people follow me, nor can I really remember the reason I follow many of the people I do. That's not to say there is one reason. I follow @shervin on twitter for his insights into angel investing and technology as much as I do his international political perspective, but the absolute lack of context makes this a very difficult problem. People continue to chase Twitter as one of the greatest sources of the social graph. I think that's an input, but in many ways, fundamentally broken. Quora has a real opportunity to both define influence and, in the end, monetize it. That is, if Joel Spolsky doesn't get there first. 

First of all, there's a huge difference between opinion and experience, which are the two of the three legs of the stool of Twitter (read that again, I made a poop joke sound really smart).  Taking on my own twitter stream, I post mostly on #startups (experience), #healthcare (experience), #softwaredevelopment (experience), #bostonsports (opinion), and #wine (opinion). Can you draw a line between these things? Maybe - you could argue because my first startup was in healthcare IT, and we did software development, those are loosely coupled. Heck, you can argue that having a startup through the last decade in Silicon Valley causes you to drink heavily. It's a flawed correlation, though. 

Additionally, I may just be a loudmouth. I may have hundreds of followers who think I'm the best at describing all the reasons the Yankees suck, which has nothing to do with any of those more intellecutal  topics. Amplification has already been proven to be a false metric, through the "Beyonce Analysis" meme.(okay, it's not a meme yet, but I want it to be) 

Twitter unintentionally threw a really big monkey wrench in this idea as well, with the Retweet ("RT").  Fundamentally, it seems simple - I trust you, so therefore, I trust the people you trust, so fill my stream up with information from them too, if you think it's worthy. I grant you proxy over my twitter stream. It is a great tool for discovery, and I find endless bits of information from people that are RT'd into my twitter stream. But is it really influence? I've argued both sides of this idea, but I currently think where we really want to put the value is on the RT'er themselves, not the post getting retweeted. I want to reward the RT'er who curated interesting information to me. 

Influence and expertise are not democratic. All votes should not be equal. HackerNews' approach of giving you a quantified number of votes is still flawed, but a worthwhile attempt. Facebook "likes" have the same context problem as a Twitter RT. 

Don't get me wrong. I think Klout (and PeerIndex) is an amazing company and I applaud them going after the big problem. They urgently have to get more people adopting their API, right now, to continue their growth. They are solving a critical problem, and I think they could be the only thing keeping Disqus from getting killed by Facebook's commenting system. That's for another post. 

So how the heck does any of this tie to Quora? Let's suppose Klout becomes one of the credit unions of the web. We need at least two, and Quora is best positioned to be the Equifax of a new generation. 

I mentioned Joel Spolsky before because I think he and the team at Stack Overflow figured out quickly one of the best ways to monetize influence and it's closely related cousin, expertise, was the the Career space. I also think Joel is extremely smart and probably saw the credit union concept long before I did. Dont be surprised if he's already on this idea.

I was in the audience at the Launch conference when Joel announced Careers 2.0. The first thought was, of course, that's genius. It seems so obvious, putting together vertical Q&A, building influence/expertise, and tying it to Careers (actually, my first thought was "LinkedIn better do that IPO soon"). The Stack Overflow platform proves that Joel's team is already thinking outside just the software development box - but there is room there to compete. I can see Quora using a very similar approach - but rather than just repeat Careers 2.0 (which they can and should do), there are several other areas that need help. 

Similar communities are popping up that can also be topical score providers. If I need to find the best designer in the word, I'm going to trust people's opinions that are in the forrst community before I trust my own brother. I love you, man, but your designs suck. Just look at companies like ShopSquad - the world is looking for ways to identify expertise and link it to solutions. The difference is, Quora is not a single topic, but trying to cover nearly all topics, crowd sourcing what topics are interesting to people. 

Here's a quick list of places where I can see Quora building solutions off it's platform that can be monitized immediatley. If ShopSquad can get $1.25M in a angel round for a small slice of this problem (but still great idea), there is money to be made here:
  • Troll-busting comment systems. There is nothing I would like more on Techcrunch then a button that said "hide comments everyone who knows nothing about this topic", which of course means MG would disappear from every page that didn't have to do with Apple.
  • Selecting an expert in healthcare, such as a doctor or dentist. There is nothing more frustrating then getting that horrific book of doctors from your insurance company, where you get to pick on based on how their name sounds. Horrible process. Experts and Influence? Sign me up.
  • Curation of content and search results identifying quality content on the web - if you don't think this is big, you're not paying attention to what Google is doing...and it's only just begun
  • Contract services, such as learning a guitar lesson or a personal trainer. 
  • What about the the College applications process? I don't know of any colleges today using your online presence to influence admissions, but it seems a natural next step. 
  • Customer support and Enterprise services - within large organizations, how we share and disseminate information, both internally and customer facing? 
  • Dating and Personal services. If you are looking for someone with certain interests, is there is any indication this person has shown any real interest in that area? Are they red state to your blue state?
  • Family and Parenting - it's easy to find advice online, but hard to quantify any of it. 
  • Real Estate - similar to Parenting, no one is an expert in the field until then choose to engage in it. Once you decide to buy a house, you're "all in" to an area which is nuanced and full of technical terminology. Who do you trust with the biggest purchase of your life?
Some of these seem like real stretches - don't get me wrong, I'm not saying I would invest or build any or all of them - but once we're able to start to contextualize and value one's contributions to the web, there is an endless array of things we can do. Quora has the ability to be the backbone of this movement. They won't be alone, as no one will trust a single overlord, but they can be hugely influential, and make some money. As it was, Equifax only made $1.8 billion in revenue in 2010. 12 more years like that, and they can save up and  buy Groupon and then make some REAL money.

Note: I broke my own rules, banged this out and posted it without enough review. It's probably disjointed and needs updating. I'll try to review it tomorrow and clean it up - feedback very welcome on how to improve it....

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Packaging your Brand

Just got a package in the mail, and I was impressed at the packaging. It looked from the outside like they spraypainted their logo on the box, which might sound funny, but for a "hip" clothing brand, I thought this was a good idea. Definatley was brand-friendly for what they are trying to convey. In fact, I wondered how they made such a realistic spray-paint/stencil look.

If you are wondering what I'm doing with a "hip" clothing brand...good point, given my geek-style - but I digress. Here are some pictures:



It was not until further inspection (that's a fancy way for saying "opening the box") that I realized - not only was it really spray painted on, the box was actually a FedEx box they turned inside out!

Now that's startup hustle (and, technically, stealing, I think, since they sent it USPS). Either way, it was a bold move, and totally caught my attention.

Sunday, March 20, 2011

Relearning to Startup, Lean

 Lean is a funny word. It has the obvious health and behavioral terminology that people often interpret as "skinny" or "fat"; Connotations of fat are rarely ever good, unless you are rapping about your wallet. Further, people extrapolate Lean to mean "cheap" as well -  thinking Lean means you never spend any money. For entrepreneurs coming out of two different economic downturns in the last decade, this also sounds appealing. In the end, however comfortable "skinny and cheap" may sound, the Lean Startup movement is really not about those things. They are symptoms and output of a Lean way of thinking, but simply re-using your Q-Tips and saving money in a heroic fashion is not lean.

I will not try to retell this history of Lean and Lean Manufacturing here, however, it's a movement that started not with Eric Ries or the internet, but inthe automotive industry, with Toyota. There are more than a few wonderful references on the web were you can understand this history - I'll start you with the wikipedia entry and one specific sentence that resonates for me:

"Lean manufacturing is a variation on the theme of efficiency based on optimizing flow; it is a present-day instance of the recurring theme in human history toward increasing efficiency, decreasing waste, and using empirical methods to decide what matters, rather than uncritically accepting pre-existing ideas."

This post allows me to tell you about some of my experiences, and some deadly pre-existing ideas that were sins of my past I'm "unlearning", to move forward in a more Lean manner. What I hope to expose you to in this post is why, as an experienced entrepreneur, I'm trying to rethink and relearn, why I'm participating in this contest, and why I believe in this movement.

A friend has told me recently Steve Blank has said "There are no 10 year startups - just 2 year startups and 8 year failures". I have no idea if Steve actually said that, as he's not said it any of the talks I've attended, but it's correct on many levels. One thing you have to understand, that will color this blog entry considerably, is that it took us ten years to get my last startup to a successful exit, and we had to pivot our way through 9/11 and the bubble bursting  in Silicon Valley. The timeline simply helps illustrate for you what the world around us was like as we started, and kept alive, my first startup.

The success of a company and entrepreneur is usually judged by the endgame - in this case, we successfully sold the company in a manner that ensured the employees and investors were all very well taken care of, something in which I take great pride. However, I think understanding the little successes and mistakes are were the real lessons are learned.

Commitment to Vendors....or Customers
The spiraling reduction in cost to startup a business today, especially in infrastructure is widely discussed, and fairly well understood. It is a reality I share as well. When we started our last startup, we hosted our infrastructure with EDS, full of  Solaris servers, Oracle database licenses, and million dollar design firm(s). We had a massive amount of money committed and infrastructure in place just to be able to test out basic ideas with customers. In other words, we had to be committed to our vendors before we had any idea how to (or what to) commit to our customers. Today, though, you can do all this and more - with real metrics and feedback analysis - with a Amazon or Joyent cluster and a few dollars per month.

Focusing on the intension of Lean - it's not about the money, but about the efficiency and focus of resources. The capital necessary to run these resources was obviously a huge drain on investment, but what about the human capital?  I am sure you are counting in your head how many people we needed to manage the servers, the relationship with EDS - even just managing the Oracle licenses themselves. Imagine if we could spend that time working with  our customers to understand what they need, and commit to our customers before committing to our vendors.

Voice of the Customer and Analytics
There are two products that really embody the Lean methodology for me, and they are User Voice and Geckboard. I'm really excited to try out both of them in a real world setting.

UserVoice is interesting to me because it most closely matches my belief of building a community of vocal, passionate, champion end users. Further, I believe these champions lead to the lowest cost, highest value acquisition strategy you can have. These champions must not only be acquired, but retained. I believe this is where tools like UserVoice fits in.

Historically, companies are more interested in acquiring your business than keeping it. Of course, they will never admit that, but Sports Illustrated never sent you a free jacket because you were a customer for five years. There are very few industries that celebrate loyalty as aggressively as they do acquisition. It's true that movements like Gary Vaynerchuck's Thank You Economy are challenging this notion, but it still has decades before it's the standard, rather than the exception. I think, implemented correctly, technologies like UserVoice can allow you to build community, feedback, forums, and a connectedness that is necessary for building and retaining passionate user base. I'm also very interested in the social media aggregation aspects of a similar product, Assistly.

As I said, I'm excited to start using  Geckoboard, a display analytics system. It can pull in data from systems like Google Analytics, CRM, and other packages, and you can configure and display dashboards on mobile, tablet, desktop, and large-format (think, 52" LCD in break room).

Here's the first sign you need Geckoboard, or something like it - you're spending more than 30 minutes a week preparing charts and graphs for executive review meetings, and then figuring out how to updated them for board meetings, all-hands meetings, and driving your business and culture, then you need a tool like Geckoboard. Spend you time analyzing the data, not formatting it. 


Steve Brown, the CEO of my first startup, used to say to me "that which is measured gets done", and he could not be more correct. This was true both for the products we were building (enabling behavioral change in chronically ill patients) and for running the business. Despite our best intentions, the work that went into building a good analytics and display platform was always priority 2, 3, or 4 while priority 0 (customer fires) and priority 1 (unvalidated product features) always took priority. We did what we could in Excel, but today, we'd make totally different choices. One of the last things I did before leaving was try to push through a few big-screen LCD purchases as the way to force the analytics process. Even though my previous company is certainly no longer a startup, analytics and information delivery is the practice of a good company, and not just startups.


QA is not a Person or and Organization. It is a culture. 
The success of companies like Zappos, and their spiritual followers Bonobos and EcoMom have championed a philosophy that everyone in the company is responsible for customer support, that it is a unique selling proposition. However, far to few organizations have applied the same concepts to quality and testing. I include myself in that group - I realized far too late in my last startup that I needed to change that, culturally.

You can see this is conceptually not so distant from our Customer Support and Metrics conversation, although culturally, the idea that the entire organization using the product and feeling (and being accountable for) quality is incredibly important. Do not bury under Customer Support and Metrics Driven aspects of your culture. I've written about this before (lovingly called eating your own dogfood), so I won't repeat that here, but I'll highlight some tools you can use to ensure that you can get this into your culture starting on "day one".

The first such tool is utest, an outsourced testing firm. As an on-demand, pay-as-you go model, they allow you to maximize your resources without making long term employment or contractual obligations. In my world, there is a huge difference between "validator" and "tester." You still need "validator"s that know your market are the voice of the customer, but the idea that you can get specific testers from utest that will execute the hand-ringing aspects of test, including, software installs, browser variations load testing,  and a myriad of other complexities absolutely invaluable. If you're sitting around saying "how have we missed that bug, it was in the last three releases!", then you need the help a service like utest can bring. 

Now, you are probably saying  "Wait, you just said eat your own dogfood" and "make quality cross-company initiative", and then, it sounds like you said outsource testing to utest. Huh? Again, the Lean aspect is not that you spend less money. Outsourcing QA to India or a low-cost provider is not the answer. It's that you did more with your available resources, be it dollars or time. In this case, we're using utest to get us more time to do the most important pieces - validation of our user experience.


Testing the product is not using the product. You need someone, like utest, to execute your test cases, but each of you in the company need to be fanatical about the user experience and the quality of the products. Test cases will pass at utest, but the experience of the user is all wrong. Test cases will pass utest (and match the specification perfectly), but you'll find your specification is wrong. 

Passing test cases is meaningless unless you are sure you built the right thing, and you can only be sure if you are passionate about feedback, iteration, and validation.  Let your vaidators rule - use mockups, use user-feedback tools, and do everything you can to remove checkbox testing out of your organization and replace it with emphatic validation.

This does not mean that your organization does not have quality professionals. Free up those intelligent people you have in test, who joined you company because they are passionate about the solution, to be part of the product, not just checking boxes in your bug tracking system. Just like Bonobos employs customer service professionals (known as Ninjas, even) even though everyone is accountable for excellent customer service , you need to employ "validators".

Mockup, down, and sideways
Hint: Consider mockup tools like Balsamiq. There are a number of great wire-framing tools in the market, but there are three things I love about Balasmiq: First, they are insanely well priced for a high quality product, so you feel like you get more than you paid for, which fits the Lean Startup theme fairly well.

Secondly, they have a good community that continues to create excellent templates and examples. I cannot think of anytime I've tried to create something I couldn't find a good example from which I could borrow, so I could keep focused on my product, and not my tools.

Finally, they have really great plugins for most major wiki and bug tracking tools (like Atlassian's Jira Studio) and lots of add on tools to create Flash Demos, HTML walkthroughs, and even an Android application (beta) . It's a great method to get feedback before you write any lines of code.

My Struggle: MVP
Finally, I should  admit some areas of Lean I struggle with - most notably, the Minimal Viable Product, or MVP.  The idea of MVP is to release a version of the product which allows you to collect the most data about your customers with the least effort. Often times, it's used as a discussion catalyst for identifying feature bloat. It's also often attributed to the Reid Hoffman quote: "If you are not embarrassed by the first version of your product, you’ve launched too late."

 I know the old way - year long development cycles, minimal feedback, exhausting timelines - none of those are the "right" way, but I am petrified of a market with minute-length attention spans, and not gaining enough "M" in my MVP to keep people engaged. This probably means I don't understand my target well enough.

The only successful way I've found, so far, of trying to get MVP to work for me is by finding a constraint, such as Luke Wroblewski's Mobile First concept.  I've already written far too much, but I can point you to Luke's presentations you can review yourself. The Mobile First movement is not specific to Lean or to MVP, but one of Luke's key points are using the limits of the mobile device screen size, bandwidth, and other constraints to focus your thinking. So many people start on the desktop, with it's endless bandwidth and large screens, and then try to "cram down" to mobile. It's actually a very empowering methodology to go the reverse direction, and works well with the MVP concept.

You probably have many good ideas for how to really get an MVP out the door and walk the fine line of engaging customers. I've not yet found that method or tool to help me do this really well, and everyday, it's on my mind. I'm looking for best practices, mentorship - hell, maybe a support group. Got ideas? I'd love to hear them in the comments below.

Being Lean
There are people  that refer to The Lean Startup movement as "common sense". I think there is no less damning description of a way of thinking then to describe it as such. However, I think that minimizes the importance of the implementation of the ideas, embodied in many of the products and services in the AppSumo Lean Startup bundle.  The  Lean Startup movement is not only conceptual ideas, but the products and processes that support them.

I don't expect you to read anything here and say "Dear Lord, Clapp as figured out a rounder wheel! Bravo!" However I do hope that putting it in the perspective of the "old way" and the "new way" will help to point out some of the subtleness, and more importantly, some of the areas I still struggle with today. A bit like someone who grew up when smoking was endorsed by doctors, I know some of my behaviors are bad for me, but I'm still having a hard time quitting them.

Let's revisit the end of the quote I introduced at the beginning of this post - not the whole thing but quite literally, the last six words:

 rather than uncritically accepting pre-existing ideas.

Hopefully I've demonstrated to you that simply following what we know from our past, our pre-existing ideas, can be a troublesome, if not deadly path for a startup. We need to mix valuable experience with decreasing waste and constantly measuring what matters, the sum of which will help us adjust priorities. Embracing Lean today is about employing the tools and best practices around you, and changing your way of thinking.

This is a way of thinking that does not stop with a book, or an AppSumo bundle, or a piece of software - the things we consider Lean today might be wasteful tomorrow. We owe it to each other, as a community, to keep pushing the definitions, the products, and the process that make up what it means to be Lean, and share best practices and failures often, openly, and with intellectual vigor.



If you would like to vote for this entry in the Lean Startup Challenge.....

Please post a tweet including the text: http://AppSumo.com/leanchallenge #leanvote67

Thank you for your consideration!

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Expectations, Ethics, and College Athletics

I usually don't write about stuff like this. First, it's dealing with religion, second, it's a team I don't care about (Sorry, BYU) and I don't follow college sports as, um, religiously as I do pro sports. Don't get me wrong, if "B" in BYU stood for Boston, I'd probably be a fan....but I digress. This is about sports journalism, and what we expect from our colleges and universities today.

Today, Brandon Davies of the BYU basketball team was dismissed for violating the teams ethics standards, known as the BYU Honor Code, which includes things like:
  • Live a chaste and virtuous life
  • Obey the law and all campus policies
  • Use clean language
  • Respect others
  • Abstain from alcoholic beverages, tobacco, tea, coffee and substance abuse
Let's start right of the top - this is just a subset of what's required, and clearly, I don't qualify, as I sit here swearing about this article, drinking my Starbucks. But I know, clearly, what the rules are. I can see how I fit in, or not. Expectations and requirements are very clear. 

ESPN covered the dismissal, which I read during lunch (after the Apple iPad2 announcement).  The article started with a good summary of how big a blow this might have been:

"A 27-2 record. A possible No. 1 seed. The best and most entertaining player in the country. A chance at a national title. Yes, BYU fans are in the midst of a dream season. The only problem with dreams? Eventually, you always have to wake up."

We're not talking about Duke or North Carolina - the idea that BYU was ranked as high as #3 in the nation, a likely number-one seed going into the tournament, this is more than a big deal for the sport of college basketball, never mind the BYU campus and state of Utah. In a season when there Utah Jazz have dismissed their long-time coach, traded away key assets, and looks non-competitive in the West for the first time in memory, BYU was the torch bearer for the region.

This had to be an agonizing decision for the school, the student, and the community. Not just because of the team, but because maybe, just maybe, they take their honor code seriously. Having a student fail either academically or socially is not a success for the university on any level. I was hoping for the rest of the article to talk about the lone bright spot in college athletics, where honor and ethics take priority over bowl standings and final-four rankings.

Instead, the article took a direction that shocked me:

"Davies is far too important to BYU's chances at a deep tournament run for this to be anything other than a serious violation, or at least "serious" relative to the Cougars' strict rules regarding student behavior at the school."

Everything that is wrong with college sports became crystallized in one sentence. Since they are good this year, it must have been a big deal. Clearly, this implies that if they were not as good "anything other than a serious violation" may have been overlooked. Further, he states "Davies is far too important to BYU's chances" - again implying that his value to the basketball team outweighs his commitment and promise he made to the University. Finally, putting serious in quotes read like a cheap-shot at the Honor Code of BYU.

I'm not Mormon, or overly religious. You could even argue that sports is my religion,  but the faux-reality of college sports has tired me to no end. These schools are openly and actively expected by sports media (and their fans, I expect) to put the sport above their honor code, their academics, and their beliefs. This is about  BYU, of all schools. The only place I could think of being less surprising for dismissing a player on ethical grounds would be The Citadel. Yet here is the media suggesting that sports could, or should, have influenced the decision.

For the thousands of alumni, and students who don't play sports at BYU, I'm personally thankful they did what they did, putting the University above the individual or the team.

I wish that was the story we were talking about.

Monday, February 28, 2011

Launch Lessons: Disrupting Networking - and a crazy idea how to go further

Introduction
At the Launch Conference last week, one of the best lines of the opening day was host Jason Calacanis informing the participants "We figured out how to make Wifi work at a conference - we ran it over ethernet". That got a good laugh from the technical folks in the crowd, all of whom were pleasantly surprized to find that every seat in the main hall had an ethernet connection.

See those white cables? That's right, we all had Ethernet.
That's right, about 1000 ethernet drops in the main conference hall, so the attendees could tweet, facebook, blog, flickr, and generally get the word out. This isn't just about knowing your audience, it's a brilliant marketing play to help promote a first time conference. Trending on Twitter? Absolutely, both days. Real time blog posts and flickr streams? You got it.

Now, it would have been easy to just provide good network connectivity to the press, which would have gotten some of the word out - but if you still think that in this world of high tech, angel investing, start-ups, and business that marketing and social value is in the hands of the few, well...you wouldn't get this point anyway. 

It was the best use of marketing dollars at a conference I'd seen in a long time. Which got me to thinking, can that be innovated any further? Here's what I came up with, and beat about with the gentleman sitting next to me on the first day, Joe Dileo.

Let me start by saying, I don't work in the telecom space, and I have no idea if the cost structures can support this - but if you know these things, leave a comment below. I'd love to learn more about the viability of the idea. For the record, I don't plan to do anything with it, I'd just like to learn.

The Idea
Every person attending the conference gets a Verizon (or insert operator here) USB wireless device, free, for attending the show. In addition, you get the first seven days, free - enough to clearly span the conference, as well as for you to check it out at your hotel.

We immediately have three "feel good" moments for Verizon and the show - I cannot believe this show got me a free device for the week, I'm saving some money not paying the hotel for wifi/network, and, I get a good network connection at the show - and to top it off, the 30% who are flying home also just saved on their airport connectivity solution. Win, win, win, win.

I think the numbers could work, although I do not have the details to prove that. These are rough numbers, but try this out:
  1. Jason said he spent "about 100k on networking" for about 1,000 people.
  2. The cost of a device without a plan is $249 on the Verizon website. You can get it for $99 with a two year plan ($149.00 hardware and additional $50 online discount).
  3. Let's pretend we can get  50% of the show to sign up for offer and an overall conversion of 30% to the 2 year plan.  
Therefore, we have 500 people take one for the 7-day offer (the rest of them have one, don't like the internet, work pays for it, or hate free stuff): Cost to supply that hardware, retail, is $124,000.

Of that, lets assume people that don't convert (200 of the 500) don't even return the hardware, worst case. So sticking with the retail numbers, that's a loss of $49,000, or half the cost of what Launch paid for networking. Again, I'm comparing retail numbers for Verizon - so the loss is not anywhere near that. You could do something like require a credit card before getting one, charge if not returned - but let's go with a more open, good-will approach. It's easy to layer on those vehicles later, if necessary.

On top of that, it means that they got 300 new subscribers - I'm pretty sure that even the top store in San Francisco does not sell 300 in a day or two day span - so isn't that worth it to some operator, if we can smooth out the numbers?

Even more disruptive, I want to BUY their impulse by waving the $99. I'll immediately show them online (with their awesome new modem) that this is the best possible price they can get and focus on getting people to sign up for two years. I'd use the tribal/group feeling of tradeshows, events, conferences to say "this is just for you, because you are part of this amazing event".

The alternative of course is making them sign up before the show, but I think that's a bad idea, and you loose the selling influence of the tribe saying "this is the best deal ever!" I think you can loss (and profit!)-share with the conference  to let people try it out first, and get some excitement around that, rather than the feeling that I've got to buy it first - make this different than the store experience.

Again, I have no data on conversion metrics for this space, or real cost data, but it feels like there is something here. I've not even touched on the marketing angle for the show and for the provider, other than a brief mention of the positive brand association that can occur.

It would seem you could become the one that solved the conference networking problem, and there are no shortage of conferences and conference attendees. Thoughts? Insanity? If you have any information on this space, the possible data or margins, or related comments, I'd love to learn from you.

If you don't agree there is a problem, check out this tweet from the Game Developers Conference (#gdc), going on now, in San Francisco.


Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Eat your own dogfood (pairs with Merlot)

In the last hour, the tweet from @danmartell  reminded me of the most important lesson I've ever learned -  and learned the hard way. Ironically, I also heard something similar from @jason Calacanis last week at the Startup Grind meetup.

Dan's words are below, and Jason's words were "if you and your team don't use [your products] everyday, something is really wrong", and he went on to talk about how he made excuses for Mahalo 1.0 on why he didn't use it, but the signs were all there that there was something not right with Mahalo 1.0, and the key was that he wasn't using it everyday. It was a very honest and enlightening discussion, and brought back memories. You can see Dan's similar comments in this picture:


If you are not using your product, you're dead-company-walking.

Although it's often attributed to startups, the honest truth is, it happens to everyone. My experience was during my time at Apple - yes, that Apple - even Apple built stuff people didn't want, once upon a time.  I'm not going to bore you with my personal backstory, but I was at Apple as a 20 year old, first working on MacApp (not the new MacApp, but a C++ framework for applications), even getting to speak about it on stage at WWDC. I then transfered over to be a tech-lead on a OpenDoc subproject called A.L.O.E. (Apple Library for Object Embedding).

Jokes about naming aside (ALOE? Remember, this is the company that brought you iPad), these were both killer jobs, where I worked with the most amazing people directly and indirectly, got my ass kicked when I wrote crappy code, and learned to be a "real" developer.

MacApp, as you can see from the Wikipedia article, had a long and successful history that I'm proud to be part of; OpenDoc - which I'm also proud to be part of, was also full amazing people, great idea, well funded, and even the same floor of the same building as the MacApp team. OpenDoc was, idea-wise, well ahead of it's time, and can be seen, conceptually, be found in most current technology. Just last year, O'Reilly posted an article about how the ideas of OpenDoc would improve the iPad experience. It was an amazing project, full of immensely talented people. But it's life was short.

I should be clear, I was not part of the core OpenDoc team like I was for MacApp3, so my point of view may be a little different than others; ALOE was a subproject. Despite what the people say about OpenDoc's failures, I think the biggest issue was we didn't use OpenDoc, or any of the products our developers or customers created.


When someone says your product is slow, that's a pretty good sign you are not using it everyday.


Sure, a few people used Cyberdog, but in general, the team didn't use OpenDoc parts such as WAV to keep meeting notes, we used Microsoft Word. We didn't use Numbers and Charts, we used Excel. None of our Apple internal tools (such as Radar, our bug tracking tool, built in...MacApp) was adopting OpenDoc.

We didn't build applications or parts we used every day, but we build a lot of demos. We should have used, every day, the things Thomas Wiesbach (and Steve Smith's team, if I remember correctly) developed; we should have built things we used (ala 37signals). Instead, we made demos and demo code. I was no better, I should have been building mashups showing how to use the tools in way I would use them, everyday, but I did not. In retrospect, it felt more like a science project to me than a product development process.

In retrospect, and worst of all, we didn't support our developers by using their products, by giving them usability and product feedback. We interacted with them in marketing and  technically (and our support team was great for technical bits), but not religiously, not as a band of people all trying to change the world. Culturally, we got that wrong. That should have been part of our manifesto, like it was on the MacApp team, where we constantly created applications, got into the developer community every day, and "ate our dogfood."

Claris did make some noise, nothing shipped, unfortunatley. If you read that linked closely, you'll see that there is Apple's wholly-owned application arm, Claris, saying "OpenDoc doesn't fit our business model". Um, time to listen to the customers! That said, there is argument that Claris actually didn't like the product technically, and Apple tried to force it down their throat. I wasn't part of that directly, although I did support Claris in some Object Embeding. In particular, Tantek (a very smart guy, by the way) moved mountains for Object Embedding and Claris. In the end, I have no idea if this is accurate or not.

When Steve Jobs came back, he specifically said "we put a bullet in OpenDoc's head".  It cost me my [at the time] dream job, as nearly the entire team was let go. The good news is, I learned a lesson very early on that I've tried to apply to every startup, every project, every idea since then. Sometimes it's hard. Sometimes you are building something for someone else (like we did with the Health Buddy), so you need to find a proxy, and do endless UX review and user feedback.

But you can't over look the simple fact - if you don't use it, why should anyone else?

Friday, December 31, 2010

You know you have a great team when....

You know you have a great team when, on your way our the door, they hit you where it hurts.

And you laugh hysterically at it.

See, yesterday was my last day at a job I've had for twelve years, for a startup we founded that had it's downs (see 2001-2003, Bubble Bursting Bingo) and ups (we grew it to the largest remote patient monitoring company in the world, and sold it to Robert Bosch Healthcare). In otherwords, a long, winding path that evokes significant emotion. Plus, I'm a sap.

I planned on writing about this decision, and transition, today - probably something slightly depressing or at least highly contemplative, fueled by an Indie-Rock Soundtrack straight out of a teen angst movie (1).  Thankfully, my amazing team of people at Health Hero/Robert Bosch Healthcare provided me with unexpected, but very welcome, comic relief.

You may already know I'm the world's second biggest Red Sox fan. This is probably a good opportunity to remind you that all Red Sox fans think they are the world's second biggest fan (Johnny Pesky of course, being in the top slot. And don't give me any of this Jerry Remy crap, either.)  The only thing you need to know about this being a Red Sox fan is that 25% (off season), 50% (in season), and 75% (playoffs or any head-to-head game) of a Red Sox fan's life is dedicated to hating the Yankees.

You'll be able to really enjoy this now, in context - this was even more funny because my car was vandalized earlier this month, so my first reply was "oh crap, not again". Here's what I found yesterday when I started lugging boxes out to my car (a few more after the break as well).




Over the years, I've had a lot of different people work for me, and I've been blessed with great programmers and developers, designers, marketers, nurses, clinicians, accountants, business developers - but more importantly, the best people. Yesterday, they proved it yet again. They made me laugh a bit on a day that could have been sad or depressing, and once again, picked me up.

I hope my future teams are as great as the ones I've had at Health Hero/Robert Bosch Healthcare, because these are top-notch people first, and professionals second. You know who you are - thanks for adding laughter to a tough day. And sadly, I can't fire you anymore. But I'll have my revenge!

Here are some more pics:


My favorite part about this, of course, is 2004 is the first year since 1918 that we finally won a World Series, after the EPIC comeback against the Yankees. My people are really smart, but their MLB history is a little weak.

For what it's worth, I also did that to a Wily Mo Pena card.
I find myself saying this over and over, but once again, Dewey Evans deserves better.

(1) For the record, I'll probably still write that piece. Someone cue up the Ben Harper and William Fitzsimmons!

Thursday, December 23, 2010

Goodnight, Major

This was written December 20th, 2010.

Tonight is Major's last day on earth. Tomorrow, he'll be peacefully put to sleep as a result of his battle with cancer, which has already cost him a leg, and has taken his breath as it moved into his lungs. Major is my Alaskan Malamute, my friend, a "sibling" to my daughter, and someone who has brought joy to nearly everyone who has met him. Dogs certainly are man's best friend, and Major is no exception.

If you'll allow me, let me tell you about Major.

One of my favorite pictures is of Major in Lake Tahoe, California, peering into the frigid water during a winter vacation. He loved the snow, he loved Tahoe. He was fascinated with the water. He could play in it for hours. That picture sums him up well - strong, curious, playful, beautiful.


Hopefully the rest of the pictures and words I've included will give you further insight into this amazing dog. Maybe it will encourage you to give to Canine Cancer research, such as the work done at the Morris Animal Foundation. Maybe it will encourage you to adopt a dog from a shelter, like Humane Society Silicon Valley. Or maybe, it will do nothing at all; but I need to write this for me, to get onto paper what a wonderful companion he has been.

Major was a rescue dog, who was found wandering the streets of Fresno, California. What a big, hairy, friendly Malamute was doing in Fresno, I'll never understand. It's even more mind boggling that someone would let a dog like Major go free. But I'm happy they did, because it lead him to me.

He eventually made his way to the Bay Area, where we found him online. Major is my second Alaskan Malamute, and just like his predecessor, Sitka, he had all of the wonderful traits of a Mal - loving, loyal, independent, vocal (including howling at every ambulance or police siren that passed him by) and unbelievably patient. He surpassed me in everyone of these qualities.

The last few months have been an emotional roller coaster with Major. When he was first diagnosed with cancer, it was a shock. He was acting a little funny, laying down in places he would not normally lay down, walking a little differently. Within a few days, there was a positive diagnosis of cancer, in his shoulder; within three weeks, his leg was removed.  While the days on the calendar passed quickly, this was an agonizing process that felt like it took years. Each day was a physical challenge for Major, and a emotional challenge for  those of us that loved him. Did we do the right thing?

People expect each other to get married, have children, change jobs - of course, these are all huge decisions. However, while I've done all these things, somehow, in retrospect, the choice to amputate felt like the first "adult" decision I made in my personal life. One that literally meant life and death. It was agonizing.  It was clear he was in tremendous pain, but the idea of life without him was just hard to fathom. The decision was made to amputate, and try chemotherapy to fight back the cancer.


Thankfully we met the wonderful people at VMS, who did an amazing job supporting both the humans and the animals. However, it was not perfect. Major actually had to have three surgeries. There were infections, issues with the dressings. It was painful for him to go back and forth.  I should say again that despite these issues, I always felt VMS has the best interests of the entire family in their work, process, and decision making. It was just the unfortunate reality of surgery and healing.

The hardest part was the recovery from the surgery. I will tell you now, I do not wish those days after his surgery on my worst enemy. The overwhelming feeling of guilt, of making the wrong decision, of putting all these human emotions on to Major was nearly unbearable. As an arctic breed, he is vocal by nature. The crying after his surgery, the despair in his eyes, you cannot possibly describe this or express to someone how that feels; this blog certainly will not correctly convey that, and if you are considering such a surgery, no one can really prepare you for it.

I cannot remember a time in my adult life breaking down like I did that first time seeing him after the amputation, being so sure of making the wrong choice, of putting this poor friend through hell. Maybe the worst was, though, the fear on my daughters face seeing him after surgery. To understand this, you have to understand their relationship. Mackenzie does not have a sibling, she has Major. I cannot really describe their relationship any more than this, but I think pictures can still expand upon the story - I am sure you can tell this spans many years - same child, same dog.


This may have been Major's greatest gift. Not only for Mackenzie, but for every child he met, Major instilled in them a confidence that animals were friends, partners, and to be loved and respected. Major earned that love and respect because he gave it out to people, who naturally returned it.

Despite his massive size and wolf-like appearance (always a big attraction to little boys at the park!) there was only one possible risk of Major being aggressive - if you were a stranger, and got close to Mackenzie, well...all bets were off. He was extremely protective of her, always on the lookout. If you were a jogger and he and Mackenzie were coming down the street together, it was best to change sides, less have Major think you're running at Mackenzie. Otherwise, the only real risk of Major doing any harm would be his rather gaseous post-meal releases, or if he rolled over on top of you. I'm still not sure how we didn't loose a cat that way.

The nights after surgery, when he came home, I slept outside with him. For two days, he cried constantly, unless he was medicated heavily. The medication sapped all his spirit, personality, and his very being. He did not want to get up, he did not want to go pee, he did not want to eat. He cried every time we tried to move him. I was sure he'd never move again. I ran over scenarios in my head over and over - how to move him, how to get him comfortable, how to keep if from getting sores or suffering from incontinence - nothing worked.

I cannot say to you that I made the right choice, that amputation was the best thing for him. I don't know. The early days, I had my doubts - very significant doubts - but over time, he recovered. It was amazing to watch him do re-learn everyday things, how to eat, go to the bathroom, even go for short walks at his advanced age. As you can see, he regained his composure, pride, and even his role as "king of the dogpark". Here's a picture of him lording over his domain.



One of the greatest experiences was taking him to the Morris Animal Foundation  K9 Cancer Walk in Los Gatos, California. He got to meet lots of other cancer dogs, some survivors, and many amputees. He was the star of the show! He me everyone, and everyone knew him. As always, he was calm, happy, peaceful, and a great ambassador not only for his breed, but for dogs in general. It was certainly the highlight of his post-surgery life, where we were able to raise money for a great cause, and he was surrounded by love and support. At the K9 walk, I met people from Tripawds,  an organization dedicated the quality of life for amputees, providing information, retail items, and  support to the large community of canine amputees. If you are considering such a surgery, you should visit their site, follow them on twitter, and join the community. It will help you.

Tomorrow is the end. It's the right choice. As much as for selfish reasons I would love to make it to the holidays, maybe one last trip to the snow, it's clear that his quality of life and his pride need to be considered. He has given so much love and respect, he deserves the same in return. The entire family will miss him immensely. I am so blessed that my daughter was exposed to such a wonderful animal, and that I've had years of joy with him. I hope I made the right choices about his amputation, and his quality of life these last few months has been has high for him as it has for those that know him, having him around.

Goodnight Major. I love you.